WHDL - 00011749

The story of relationship: a narrative inquiry into mentor teacher perceptions of their mentoring experiences with teaching candidates

Serena Hicks

Description / Abstract

The relationship between pre-service teachers and their mentor teachers has long been defined by roles that mentor teachers play in the relationship. Research indicates that mentor teachers evolve into a variety of roles, from evaluator to critical friend, but we understand very little about how the relationship develops into these different forms, or how to improve relationship development. The purpose of this narrative inquiry was to explore how a mentor teacher experiences the relationship with a pre-service teacher candidate and to compare the relationship to the elements of a story. Data was collected through written story, interviews, and visual representations of the data. The goal of the study was to understand how mentor teachers experienced their relationship with a pre-service teacher candidate through the lens of a common Narrative Story Arc. Data was analyzed using codes determined by the Narrative Story Arc and through emergent codes present in narrative surveys and semi-structured interviews. Themes and codes were then compared between methods and participants, then recoded to explore themes in the data to demonstrate connections between codes. Findings from this research reveal the following: 1. Mentor teachers experience a variety of emotions in their relationship that shift based on the alignment between their expectations and reality; they experience the relationship through collaboration, a desire to help, and concern for their students. 2. Data demonstrates a connection between the teaching candidate’s perceived personality traits and abilities in pedagogy or management and the mentor teacher’s willingness to engage in a positive relationship. 3. Mentor teachers provide access or withhold access to teaching and learning in the practicum placement based in part on the relationship that develops.4. Mentor teachers conceptualize their relationship with a teaching candidate in terms of a story, indicating that the beginning of the story determines access to teaching; the events of the story open or close access to learning and the way in which conflict resolves. Specifically, this study informs teacher preparation programs and stakeholders how to mitigate disruptive emotions, outlines steps to communicate expectations, and confirms the importance of attending to the beginning of the relationship between a mentor teacher and a teaching candidate.

The story of relationship: a narrative inquiry into mentor teacher perceptions of their mentoring experiences with teaching candidates

Description / Abstract

Download this Resource

Download Free from WHDL

Collections With This Resource

NNU Graduate Education Dissertations

Related Resources

"For This We Stand", Values Document

“Not so backwards”: a phenomenological study on the lived experiences of high achieving post-secondary students with dyslexia

2016-17 APNTS President's Report

A case study investigating collaborative working environments at the secondary level and the influence on student achievement

A case study on the elements of school culture and the potential effect on student achievement at the rural middle school level

A comprehensive model of instructional leadership: The effects of middle school leadership on growth in student learning

A mixed method study to measure the impact of mastery-based, personalized learning on at-risk student achievement

A mixed methods research study investigating the influence of technology on offender mindset, resilience, and self-efficacy in Northwest correctional facilities

A mixed methods study examining the instructional environment for students with autism in general education elementary classrooms

A mixed methods study exploring the perceptions of elementary principals regarding grade retention of kindergarten and first grade students in rural Idaho districts

A mixed methods study exploring transformative learning through a Christian discipleship process

A mixed methods study investigating parental involvement and student success in high school online education

A mixed-methods approach discovering the impact on reading fluency of struggling kindergarten students when receiving a double dose of literacy instruction

A mixed-methods study examining the role of the instructional coach within a professional learning community

A phenomenological study of Hawaii independent school teachers' use of alternative assessments

A qualitative investigation on the impact of memes on student engagement in 7th and 8th grade English Language Arts

A qualitative study exploring the role of professional relationships of school climate in teacher retention in public middle schools

A qualitative study exploring the use of online education to overcome the educational challenges faced by out of school youth

A qualitative study investigating administrator perceptions on the need, benefits, challenges, and areas for principal mentoring

A quantitative study exploring grading and assessment practices in the middle school environment

A quantitative study exploring literacy and career technical education instructional beliefs in Idaho schools

A quantitative study investigating the critical ninth-grade year and how grit influences student academic success

A quantitative study investigating the efficacy beliefs of elementary teachers including a specific emphasis on mathematics

A quantitative study of Idaho high school seniors' postsecondary decision-making influences

A role of the rural elementary principal: Increasing reading literacy in third graders living in poverty through advocating community partnerships

About the Authors

Serena Hicks